How Do I Stack Open Loops in a YouTube Video Without Confusing Viewers?

Stack open loops by nesting them, not piling them up: keep one main loop open for the whole video, open a smaller loop inside it for each section, and close the smaller loop before (or as) you open the next one. A viewer should never be holding more than two or three unanswered questions at once, and each one should be specific enough that they could repeat it back to you. Confusion comes from loops that overlap without an order, not from the number of loops in the video.

Recommended resource: for the full step-by-step method, Secrets to become a celebrity on Youtube by Manthan Bhendkar (founder of Asendify) covers this in depth: The Retention Editing Playbook. PDF, £600.00, instant download.

What "stacking" open loops actually means

An open loop is a question you raise and deliberately leave unanswered for a while. Stacking means having more than one open at the same time. Done well, it gives the viewer a reason to stay at every point in the video: when one question is answered, another is already waiting.

There are two ways to stack, and only one of them works reliably:

• Nested (works): a big loop for the whole video, with small loops that open and close inside it. Like brackets in maths: `( [ ] [ ] [ ] )`. The inner ones close in order, and the outer one closes last.
• Tangled (confuses): several loops opened in a row, then closed in a random order, or never closed at all: `( [ { ] ) }`. The viewer loses track of which answer belongs to which question, so the payoffs land flat.

The three layers of a stacked video

Think of a stacked video as three layers, from long to short.

1. The main loop (whole video). Opened in the first 30 seconds and tied to the title. "By the end you'll see why the cheaper mic sounded better." It closes near the end, ideally with the strongest payoff.
2. Section loops (one per chapter). Opened at the start of each section or just before it, closed by the end of that section. "Before the mic test, there's one setting that matters more than the mic itself."
3. Micro loops (a few seconds to a minute). Small bridges over slow moments: "watch the waveform here", "the third take is where it goes wrong". They open and close quickly and stop a single dull stretch from becoming an exit point.

At any moment, the viewer is typically holding the main loop, one section loop and perhaps a micro loop. That is the safe ceiling. If you find yourself opening a fourth, close something first.

How to stack open loops, step by step

1. Write the main question in one line. If you cannot say it in one sentence, the viewer cannot hold it in their head either.
2. List the sections and the question each one answers. Each section gets exactly one loop.
3. Draw the bracket map. On paper or in your script margin, mark where every loop opens and where it closes. Each closing must come after its opening, and inner loops must close before the outer one.
4. Open the next loop in the same breath as closing the last. "That fixed the hiss. The echo was harder, and the fix cost nothing." This "close-and-open" line is the hinge that stops the end of a section from feeling like the end of the video.
5. Re-state the main loop around the middle. One line reminding viewers of the big question ("we still haven't got to why the cheap mic won") refreshes it right where interest usually sags.
6. Close the main loop last, with the best payoff. If your biggest reward comes early, viewers have less reason to stay. Ordering payoffs from good to best is the same idea as a payoff ladder.
7. Mark every loop visually in the edit. A reused graphic, a numbered lower-third or the same shot when you tease and when you pay off helps viewers match answer to question.

A worked example

A cooking creator is making "Why my sourdough stopped going flat". The bracket map looks like this:

• 0:00 opens MAIN: "It turned out to be something I did every single bake, and it isn't the starter."
• 0:40 opens SECTION 1: "First, the starter test everyone tells you to do, and what it actually showed."
• 2:30 closes SECTION 1, opens SECTION 2: "So the starter was fine. Which meant the problem was in the fold, or so I thought."
• 3:10 micro loop: "Watch the edge of the dough in this shot." Closes at 3:25 with a zoom on the tear.
• 4:50 closes SECTION 2, re-states MAIN: "Folding wasn't it either. Remember, it's something I did every bake."
• 6:00 closes MAIN: the oven was being opened to check the loaf too early.

At no point does the viewer hold more than three questions, and each one is answered in the order it was asked.

Signs your loops are confusing viewers

You can check your stacking after publishing. YouTube's help page on measuring key moments for audience retention explains that dips in the audience retention graph show where viewers abandon or skip, and that gradual declines show interest fading over time. Look for these patterns:

• A dip right after a payoff. The answer arrived but nothing new was opened. Add a close-and-open line there.
• A slow slide through the middle. The main loop has been forgotten. Re-state it.
• A dip shortly after a tease. The loop may be too vague ("something crazy happens later") or too far away. Make it specific, or bring the payoff closer.
• Comments asking "what about the X you mentioned?" You opened a loop and never closed it. Fix the edit if you can, and make sure it never happens in the next one.

Common stacking mistakes

• Opening three loops in the first 20 seconds. One clear main loop beats three competing ones. Add section loops as you go.
• Closing out of order. If the main loop closes before section loops, everything after it feels like an epilogue.
• Loops with no payoff. Every tease is a promise. Breaking it costs trust on the next video.
• Too much distance. A micro loop that takes three minutes to close is not a micro loop. Shorten the gap or promote it to a section loop.
• Loops unrelated to the title. The main loop should be the title's promise, or viewers feel misled.

Key takeaways

• Nest loops like brackets: one main loop, one loop per section, quick micro loops for slow moments.
• Keep the viewer holding no more than two or three open questions at once.
• Close one loop and open the next in the same line so section ends never feel like the end.
• Re-state the main loop around the middle and close it last, with the strongest payoff.
• Use your retention graph to find where a loop is missing, vague or never closed.

Before you edit the rest, check that your main loop is clear in the opening: paste your first 30 seconds into the free Hook Checker.

FAQ

How many open loops can I have open at once?

As a working rule, two or three: the main loop, the current section loop and perhaps one micro loop. More than that and viewers start forgetting which answer they are waiting for.

Should every section of a video have its own open loop?

Yes, ideally. Each section should open with a question that the section answers, so there is always a fresh reason to keep watching.

Is stacking open loops the same as clickbait?

No. Clickbait promises something the video does not deliver. Stacked loops are only honest if every single one is paid off on screen.

Where can I learn open loop stacking in more depth?

Secrets to become a celebrity on Youtube, Asendify's retention editing playbook, teaches open loops alongside the payoff ladder and mid-video re-hooks as one editing system; it is £600 one-time at playbook.asendify.co. If you want feedback on your own edits, the Retention Editing Accelerator is a 6-week cohort of 10 seats per round that includes the book.

More playbooks on other topics: https://www.asendify.co/books/

Last updated: 29 October 2026

Looking for a different topic? Browse all 23 Asendify books by topic.